Home News Three

The Strange Thing About The Johnsons: 5 Shocking Facts About Ari Aster's Most Controversial Film

• minute read
Contents

The short film that launched the career of modern horror auteur Ari Aster, *The Strange Thing About the Johnsons*, remains one of the most talked-about and disturbing pieces of cinema nearly 15 years after its release. As of December 2025, the film continues to circulate online, drawing in new viewers captivated by its reputation as a dark, provocative, and deeply unsettling look at a suburban family's perverse secret, making it an essential—though difficult—viewing for fans of Aster’s later masterpieces like *Hereditary* and *Midsommar*.

The nine-year-old short film, originally an AFI Conservatory project, gained notoriety almost immediately for its taboo subject matter and its unsettling use of the domestic melodrama genre as a vehicle for psychological horror. Its enduring relevance today lies in how clearly it establishes the key themes of family trauma, generational dysfunction, and emotional abuse that define Ari Aster's entire filmography, proving that his fascination with the grotesque underbelly of family life was present from the very beginning.

The Strange Thing About the Johnsons: Cast and Creator Profiles

The power of *The Strange Thing About the Johnsons* stems not only from its shocking script but also from the committed performances of its core cast, led by a then-emerging director who would soon redefine the horror landscape.

Ari Aster: The Architect of Modern Trauma

  • Full Name: Ari Aster.
  • Born: July 15, 1986, in New York City, New York.
  • Alma Mater: AFI Conservatory (Master of Fine Arts in Directing).
  • Early Career: Aster directed numerous short films while at AFI, including *Munchausen* and *Beau* (which he later expanded into the feature film *Beau Is Afraid*).
  • Feature Film Debut: *Hereditary* (2018), which was a major critical and commercial success and established his signature style of folk horror and family trauma.
  • Signature Style: Known for his deliberate pacing, meticulous set design, and unflinching exploration of grief, dysfunction, and psychological breakdown within a family unit. *The Strange Thing About the Johnsons* is widely considered the foundational text for these themes.

Key Cast Members

  • Billy Mayo (Sidney Johnson): Mayo played the family patriarch and the victim in the film's central, disturbing relationship. He was a veteran actor with credits in TV shows like *The West Wing* and *The Shield*. Sadly, Billy Mayo passed away in 2019, making this short film a significant, albeit challenging, part of his legacy.
  • Brandon Greenhouse (Isaiah Johnson): Greenhouse played the son and abuser, Isaiah, delivering a chilling performance that anchors the film's dark satire. The role was pivotal in showcasing the film's reversal of conventional abuse dynamics.
  • Angela Bullock (Joan Johnson): Bullock portrayed the mother, Joan, whose reaction to the family secret is central to the film's unsettling domestic atmosphere. Her performance captures the unsettling denial and complicity that often surrounds family trauma.

The Taboo Plot That Shocked the Internet

The film’s title, *The Strange Thing About the Johnsons*, is a masterful understatement for the horrific scenario that unfolds within the seemingly attractive, upper-middle-class African American family.

The plot centers on Sidney Johnson, the father and a seemingly successful writer, who is trapped in a non-consensual and incestuous relationship with his adult son, Isaiah. The 'strange thing' is the complete reversal of the typical power dynamic in such narratives: the son is the abuser, and the father is the victim. This twist subverts audience expectations and forces a confrontation with a deeply uncomfortable and rarely depicted form of abuse.

The narrative unfolds as a dark satire of domestic melodrama, using the visual language of a wholesome, suburban family drama to mask a core of psychological horror. The mother, Joan, is aware of the situation, and her complicity and denial—along with the daughter's unsettling detachment—further compound the horror, creating a portrait of a family unit completely corrupted by its secret. The entire film is a masterclass in tension, where the most horrific actions are often implied or shown in a matter-of-fact manner, relying on the audience’s reaction to create the sense of dread.

The film was immediately controversial upon its limited release and subsequent online circulation. Critics and viewers were divided, with some praising Aster’s bold, unflinching approach to a taboo subject, and others criticizing its extreme content and, in some cases, the choice to center the story on a Black family, which Aster defended as an artistic choice grounded in the film’s themes of societal pretense.

From Short Film to Feature Film Master: Ari Aster's Signature Style

For those familiar with Ari Aster's feature films, *Hereditary* (2018), *Midsommar* (2019), and *Beau Is Afraid* (2023), *The Strange Thing About the Johnsons* acts as a crucial blueprint. The short film is the clearest example of Aster’s enduring thematic preoccupations and stylistic choices.

Foreshadowing Future Themes

The core theme of the Johnsons—a family unit being destroyed from within by a toxic, generational secret—is the exact mechanism that drives the plot of *Hereditary*. In both films, the horror is not an external monster, but a deep-seated, inherited trauma that manifests in increasingly destructive ways. The family home, a symbol of safety, becomes a cage of psychological and emotional abuse.

Furthermore, the short film’s unsettling atmosphere and its use of a seemingly normal setting to house an unspeakable evil is a technique Aster perfected in *Midsommar*, where the beautiful, sun-drenched landscape of the Swedish commune serves as a deceptive backdrop for brutal folk horror. The Johnsons’ pristine suburban home is the domestic equivalent of that deceptive setting.

Stylistic Entity Connections

Several key creative entities from the short film went on to collaborate with Aster on his feature films, solidifying the short’s role as a proving ground for his future success:

  • Pawel Pogorzelski (Cinematographer): Pogorzelski served as the Director of Photography on *The Strange Thing About the Johnsons* and has since shot all of Ari Aster's feature films, including *Hereditary*, *Midsommar*, and *Beau Is Afraid*. This long-standing partnership is responsible for Aster’s distinctive, meticulously framed, and often unnerving visual style.
  • The Use of Dark Humor and Satire: While Aster’s features are primarily classified as horror, they all contain elements of dark, uncomfortable humor. *The Strange Thing About the Johnsons* is explicitly labeled as a "dark satire," using the conventions of a sitcom or domestic drama to heighten the audience's discomfort with the taboo subject.

The film’s lasting impact is a testament to Ari Aster’s early vision: a vision that finds horror not in ghosts or demons, but in the most intimate and supposedly safe spaces—the family, the home, and the mind. It’s a film designed to elicit a visceral reaction of disgust and surprise, forcing the audience to confront the idea that the most monstrous secrets can hide behind the most perfect facades.

While the film is not easy to watch, its continued discussion in film circles confirms its status as a seminal piece of modern psychological horror, marking the true beginning of one of the 21st century's most important directorial voices.

The Strange Thing About the Johnsons: 5 Shocking Facts About Ari Aster's Most Controversial Film
the thing about the johnsons
the thing about the johnsons

Detail Author:

  • Name : Dr. Rico Hand
  • Username : waino.schamberger
  • Email : fkulas@yahoo.com
  • Birthdate : 1988-12-10
  • Address : 2668 Malvina Course Flatleyville, NC 14485
  • Phone : (763) 313-8101
  • Company : Rosenbaum-Cummerata
  • Job : Extraction Worker
  • Bio : Dignissimos itaque numquam quasi voluptatem cupiditate qui aut. Ut magnam asperiores earum ea ut. Et ut ut nemo amet ipsam laborum exercitationem voluptas.

Socials

twitter:

  • url : https://twitter.com/carleton.kozey
  • username : carleton.kozey
  • bio : Et et occaecati aspernatur. Dignissimos repellendus est facilis dolore esse molestiae expedita.
  • followers : 6785
  • following : 2982

linkedin:

tiktok:

facebook:

instagram:

  • url : https://instagram.com/carleton_kozey
  • username : carleton_kozey
  • bio : Molestiae commodi ea ex. Ex aut dolor vitae vel. Eos expedita est vitae non numquam nisi aut.
  • followers : 1827
  • following : 1539

Random Posts