Home News Leg 4

The Shocking Truth: What Did Jeremiah’s Letter Say In TSITP? (And Why It Wasn't For Him)

• minute read
Contents

The Summer I Turned Pretty love triangle is defined by secrets, stolen moments, and, crucially, a mother's final words. As of this December 2025 update, the most highly anticipated and emotionally devastating plot point from the book series, Susannah Fisher's wedding letters, has become the center of fan discussion, particularly the enigmatic letter Jeremiah Fisher receives. This seemingly small piece of paper holds the key to the entire 'Jelly' and 'Bonrad' dynamic, acting as the ultimate catalyst that forces Belly, Conrad, and Jeremiah to face their true feelings and the painful reality of their situation.

The mystery surrounding this letter is a direct adaptation of the third book, We'll Always Have Summer, and its dramatic reveal is set to be one of the most heartbreaking scenes in the series. What Jeremiah reads is not a heartfelt message tailored just for him, but a devastating mix-up that confirms the deep, unspoken connections Susannah knew existed between her sons and Belly Conklin.

The Fisher Family's Final Words: Susannah's Letters and the Mix-Up

The emotional core of The Summer I Turned Pretty revolves around the legacy of Susannah Fisher and her unconditional love for her children, Jeremiah and Conrad, and her 'summer girl,' Belly. Battling her cancer, Susannah decided to write individual letters to the three people she loved most, to be opened on their respective wedding days, ensuring her presence would be felt even after she was gone. These letters were a final, poignant gift.

  • The Recipients: Susannah wrote separate letters for Belly Conklin, Conrad Fisher, and Jeremiah Fisher.
  • The Keeper: Laurel Conklin, Belly's mother and Susannah's best friend, was entrusted with keeping these letters safe until the right time.
  • The Origin of the Confusion: In a flashback during Season 2, a scene reveals Laurel accidentally knocking over the tray holding the carefully labeled envelopes, leading to the crucial mix-up. This seemingly minor accident sets the stage for the massive emotional fallout in the third season.

The Fateful Day: When Jeremiah Opened the Letter

The dramatic climax of the book's narrative—and the expected high point of the show's third season—occurs on the day of Belly and Jeremiah's wedding. The young couple, having rushed into an engagement at college, are preparing to marry, much to the quiet disapproval of their families. Amidst the chaos and tension, Conrad, ever the protector, gives Jeremiah the letter he believes is his mother's final blessing for his marriage.

Jeremiah opens the envelope, expecting words of maternal pride and support for his union with Belly. Instead, the contents are shockingly, painfully specific, but they are not for him. The letter he reads is the one Susannah wrote for Conrad.

The Full, Heartbreaking Content of the Letter

The letter Jeremiah opens is meant for his older brother, Conrad. The words, while beautiful, immediately expose the truth of the mix-up and, more devastatingly, Susannah's perception of Conrad's one true love. The content is an emotional gut-punch that shatters the illusion of Belly and Jeremiah's hurried wedding.

The letter begins with a clear address to Conrad, referencing his nature as the "little big" brother:

“Dear Conrad, I can hardly believe my little big is getting married today! I am just bursting at the thought that my beautiful boy has found the person he wants to spend his life with.”

While this part is painful enough, the most critical section of the letter—the part that solidifies the end of the 'Jelly' relationship and the inevitability of 'Bonrad'—is a detail Jeremiah later reveals to Belly. Susannah wrote about Conrad's capacity for love, a line that speaks volumes about her understanding of her sons:

"She said she only ever saw you genuinely in love once—with Belly."

Another powerful sentiment from the letters, which reinforces Susannah's desire for her children's happiness, is a quote about the ultimate gift of love:

“As a mother, there is no greater gift than to see her child be so dearly loved by another person.”

For Jeremiah, reading these words on his wedding day is the ultimate betrayal, not from Belly or Conrad, but from the universe. It confirms that his mother, the person who loved him most, recognized that his brother and his fiancée shared an undeniable, singular connection that transcended everything else. It’s the final, irrefutable proof that Belly and Conrad are meant to be together.

The Letter’s Impact: Why It Ended the Engagement

The accidental reading of Conrad’s letter serves as the final, dramatic turning point in the love triangle. It’s the moment the emotional dam breaks, leading to a massive confrontation between the two Fisher brothers and Belly.

  • The Confrontation: The letter acts as a catalyst for a literal fight between Jeremiah and Conrad. The years of unspoken resentment, jealousy, and competition over Belly Conklin finally boil over in a physical altercation.
  • Jeremiah’s Realization: The words force Jeremiah to confront the reality that his mother, the person he cherished, saw the depth of Conrad’s love for Belly in a way she didn't see his. This realization, coupled with his own doubts about the rushed marriage, makes him furious and heartbroken.
  • The Breakup: Following the fight and the devastating letter reveal, Belly makes the painful but necessary decision to call off the wedding. The letter, meant for Conrad, ironically gives Jeremiah the clarity he needed to accept that he couldn't marry Belly to "erase" Conrad or the history they shared.
  • The Resolution: Ultimately, the letters fulfill their purpose, though not in the way Susannah intended. They force all three characters—Belly, Conrad, and Jeremiah—to stop running from the truth and allow the destined 'Bonrad' endgame to begin, years after their first summer at Cousins Beach.

Key Entities and Themes in the Letter's Aftermath

The aftermath of the letter's reveal is rich with thematic and character development, touching on numerous key elements of the series:

Character Development: Conrad Fisher finally steps up, having to chase after a distraught Jeremiah to convince him to return and face Belly. Jeremiah Fisher is forced to mature and accept that love isn't always fair. Belly Conklin finds the courage to stop wavering and make her final, painful choice.

Setting and Symbolism: The wedding, which was meant to be a joyous occasion at Cousins Beach, is instead a scene of ultimate heartbreak, forever changing the meaning of the beloved beach house for the Fisher family.

Thematic Elements: The plot highlights the complexity of the love triangle, the enduring power of first love, the painful reality of growing up, and the deep, lasting impact of Susannah's legacy on her sons and Belly. The letter is the final push, the ultimate piece of evidence that the 'Jelly' relationship was a beautiful, but ultimately temporary, detour from the 'Bonrad' destiny.

The Shocking Truth: What Did Jeremiah’s Letter Say In TSITP? (And Why It Wasn't For Him)
what did jeremiah's letter say tsitp
what did jeremiah's letter say tsitp

Detail Author:

  • Name : Amir Gulgowski MD
  • Username : zvolkman
  • Email : andreane.heidenreich@gmail.com
  • Birthdate : 1974-07-10
  • Address : 342 Schultz Plains Aliyaville, WY 09255
  • Phone : 651.869.6645
  • Company : Larson Ltd
  • Job : Budget Analyst
  • Bio : Dicta sequi laboriosam amet odio ab. Optio iure eos qui eum assumenda itaque occaecati. Autem deleniti esse dolorum mollitia voluptas. Quae sunt fuga expedita reiciendis.

Socials

twitter:

  • url : https://twitter.com/michelemcdermott
  • username : michelemcdermott
  • bio : Nemo est totam enim porro. Veritatis rerum dolor ex et blanditiis explicabo. Est ut rerum qui quidem.
  • followers : 5263
  • following : 2736

linkedin:

facebook:

Random Posts