Home News Leg 3

The 10 Best Restaurants In Millersburg, Ohio: A 2025 Culinary Guide To Amish Country's Hidden Gems

• minute read
Contents

Planning a trip to Ohio's Amish Country in late 2025? Millersburg, the charming seat of Holmes County, offers a surprisingly diverse and vibrant culinary scene that extends far beyond the traditional comfort food the region is famous for. While classic Amish-style dining remains a cornerstone of the local experience, a wave of new, trendy establishments and premier fine dining spots has elevated the area, ensuring every palate finds a memorable meal.

This comprehensive, up-to-date guide for December 21, 2025, cuts through the noise to highlight the absolute best, most current, and most unique dining destinations in Millersburg, Ohio. From award-winning craft breweries to farm-to-table excellence, prepare to discover the hidden culinary gems that make this small town a must-visit food destination.

The New & Noteworthy: Trendy Spots and Craft Beer Culture

Millersburg's dining landscape is rapidly evolving, blending its historic charm with modern culinary concepts. These spots represent the freshest, most talked-about places to eat right now, offering a contemporary twist on local flavors and a vibrant atmosphere.

1. The Cider Press: The Trendy Newcomer

The Cider Press has quickly established itself as a must-visit spot, bringing a modern, lively atmosphere to downtown Millersburg.

  • Vibe: Trendy, local, and focused on showcasing a rich variety of local ingredients.
  • Must-Try Dishes: Patrons rave about the rich Blackened Chicken Alfredo and the flavorful Italian Sausage Pasta. For a unique pub appetizer, the Fried Pickle Chips are a local favorite. They also serve up excellent roasted sandwiches and tasty cinnamon rolls.
  • Why It's Fresh: It's one of the newer, more exciting additions to the Millersburg dining scene, offering a fresh take on American comfort food with a focus on good company and a memorable dining experience.

2. Millersburg Brewing Company: Award-Winning Pub Fare

Located in beautiful downtown Millersburg, the Millersburg Brewing Company is more than just a place for award-winning craft beer; it's a destination for high-quality pub fare.

  • The Food Focus: Their menu is known for its eclectic pub grub. The star of the show is the half-pound burgers, which are made with a premium blend of short rib, chuck, and brisket, served on a toasted brioche bun.
  • The Beer: The brewery is known for local favorites like the Millersburg 7 Lick Hill German Hefeweizen and the Millersburg Anndrew Ice Amber Ale.
  • Atmosphere: A cool combination of historic façade and urban interior elements, making it a great spot for a casual dinner or a night out across from the Holmes County Courthouse.

3. Bags Sports Pub: The Local Favorite

A true local institution, Bags Sports Pub is the go-to for classic pub-style food and a lively, golf-themed environment.

  • Menu Highlight: The food served on a pretzel bun is highly recommended by locals, offering a satisfying, savory twist on typical pub sandwiches.
  • The Vibe: Known for its great variety of food and cocktails, making it a reliable spot for a casual lunch or dinner.

Premier Dining: Where to Find Fine Dining and Elevated Cuisine

For those seeking a more sophisticated or romantic dining experience, Millersburg offers options that focus on contemporary cuisine, local sourcing, and an elevated atmosphere, often nestled within the area's top boutique hotels.

4. Tarragon at The Inn at Honey Run: A 2025 Culinary Update

Tarragon is the premier fine dining establishment in the area, situated within the beautiful Inn at Honey Run. The experience here is centered on modern cuisine, often with a European focus, complemented by fresh, local ingredients.

  • The 2025 Menu: The latest menu updates push the limit on classic favorites. Entree highlights include the stunning Pan-Seared Venison topped with cranberry compote and a perfectly prepared Ribeye Steak.
  • Chef's Recommendations: Look out for the signature Roasted Chicken with a smoky lemon honey glaze or the deeply flavorful Braised Pork Osso Bucco paired with celery root puree and sour cherry.
  • Experience: Tarragon offers an award-winning contemporary dining experience unique to the region, making it the perfect choice for a special occasion or a luxurious meal.

5. The Station Restaurant: Historic Charm

The Station Restaurant is a top-rated dining spot that offers a comfortable, welcoming atmosphere. While details on its specific menu are often seasonal, it is consistently mentioned as one of the area's best overall restaurants, known for its hearty meals and excellent service.

The Heart of Holmes County: Authentic Amish and Homestyle Cooking

No trip to Millersburg is complete without experiencing the authentic, hearty, and generous portions of traditional Amish and homestyle cooking. These restaurants are the backbone of the local culinary identity.

6. Berlin Farmstead: The Classic Amish Buffet

Located near Millersburg in nearby Berlin, the Berlin Farmstead is a staple of Amish Country dining. It is consistently ranked among the best places for a traditional dinner experience.

  • The Experience: Known for its extensive buffet and family-style meals, it provides the quintessential Amish Country dining experience with classic comfort foods.
  • Local Tip: It’s a great choice for those looking to sample a wide variety of traditional dishes in one sitting.

7. Maw Maw's Diner: Homestyle Comfort

Maw Maw's Diner offers a more intimate, classic diner experience in Millersburg. This family-style restaurant is a reliable choice for simple, well-executed comfort food and a cozy atmosphere that reflects the local hospitality of Ohio's Amish Country.

8. Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant (Berlin): Over 75 Years of Tradition

While technically in Berlin, just a short drive from Millersburg, Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant has been serving the area for over 75 years. This family-owned institution is revered for its down-home, Amish-style cooking.

  • All-Day Dining: They serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner, making it a perfect spot for any meal.
  • The Desserts: Be sure to save room for their homemade pies and desserts—a hallmark of Amish Country cooking.

Breakfast, Lunch, and Quick Bites

For those starting their day or looking for a quick, delicious midday meal, Millersburg has fantastic options that focus on fresh ingredients and cozy settings.

9. Blue Sky Cafe: The Breakfast & Lunch Destination

Blue Sky Cafe is a highly-rated spot specifically known for its breakfast and lunch offerings.

  • Menu Highlights: They offer a variety of sandwiches and customizable breakfast bowls, perfect for a quick and satisfying start to your day exploring Holmes County.

10. Brick Towne Tavern: Casual & Convenient

Brick Towne Tavern is frequently listed among the top-rated restaurants near Millersburg. It provides a casual and convenient setting for a quick bite or a relaxed evening meal, known for its friendly service and consistent quality.

Essential Entities for Your Millersburg Culinary Tour

To fully experience the depth of Millersburg's culinary authority, consider these additional entities and nearby gems:

  • Chalet In The Valley Restaurant: A classic dining spot offering Swiss and American cuisine near Charm/Millersburg.
  • Grover's Restaurant & Tavern: Another local favorite providing a relaxed atmosphere and satisfying meals.
  • Coblentz Chocolate Company: Essential for taking home great desserts and goodies, a true Amish Country treat.
  • Rebecca's Bistro (Walnut Creek): Highly recommended for a phenomenal breakfast or lunch just a short drive away.
  • Der Dutchman (Walnut Creek): Another major destination for traditional Amish cooking, often featuring a large buffet and baked goods.
The 10 Best Restaurants in Millersburg, Ohio: A 2025 Culinary Guide to Amish Country's Hidden Gems
restaurants in millersburg ohio
restaurants in millersburg ohio

Detail Author:

  • Name : Dr. Colten Dickens Jr.
  • Username : vladimir81
  • Email : fhilpert@hansen.biz
  • Birthdate : 1991-11-09
  • Address : 78154 Raphaelle Rapid Suite 858 Brownbury, KY 58935
  • Phone : +14805595899
  • Company : Volkman, Mueller and Larkin
  • Job : Recreation Worker
  • Bio : Atque molestiae ullam nemo. Officiis ut voluptas provident eaque sint. Placeat maxime vel consequuntur itaque id. Recusandae quasi numquam et laborum illum.

Socials

linkedin:

twitter:

  • url : https://twitter.com/jettie_xx
  • username : jettie_xx
  • bio : Dolores ut sapiente repellat veritatis sit. Eius repudiandae beatae architecto nemo. Unde nihil dolor blanditiis pariatur modi aut tempora.
  • followers : 3597
  • following : 2057

tiktok:

  • url : https://tiktok.com/@jettie_official
  • username : jettie_official
  • bio : Esse eum in quia consequatur. Rerum mollitia beatae ut temporibus ut pariatur.
  • followers : 1255
  • following : 1974

facebook:

instagram:

  • url : https://instagram.com/pacocha1988
  • username : pacocha1988
  • bio : Et officiis eligendi sit. Veniam est voluptate eum blanditiis iure quidem voluptatem.
  • followers : 1340
  • following : 545

Random Posts