5 Shocking Truths Behind Why Shilo Sanders Didn't Land With The Pittsburgh Steelers In The 2025 NFL Draft

As of December 21, 2025, the buzz connecting Shilo Sanders to the Pittsburgh Steelers has officially turned into a discussion of a massive, missed opportunity. The son of NFL legend Deion Sanders, Shilo Sanders, went completely undrafted in the 2025 NFL Draft, a shocking outcome for a player who led the Colorado Buffaloes defense. The Steelers, a franchise known for its defensive prowess and desperate for safety depth, had multiple chances to select him, yet General Manager Omar Khan remained silent, allowing Sanders to sign with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers as an undrafted free agent (UDFA). This decision has left the 'Steelers Nation' fanbase scratching its head, wondering what red flags caused Pittsburgh to avoid adding a high-IQ, hard-hitting safety to their roster. The intrigue surrounding Shilo Sanders and the black and gold was palpable, fueled by his aggressive playing style and the natural storyline of a 'Prime Time' legacy player joining a historic defense. However, the reality of the 2025 draft revealed a different path. This article dives deep into the scouting reports, the Steelers' current roster needs, and the specific factors that led to the surprising disconnect between Shilo Sanders and the Pittsburgh Steelers organization.

Shilo Sanders: Complete Player Biography and Profile

Shilo Deion Sanders is a professional football safety whose collegiate journey was marked by resilience and a move to follow his father, Deion Sanders, through multiple programs. Born on February 9, 2000, in Canton, Texas, Shilo has always been in the spotlight, carrying the name of one of the greatest defensive backs in NFL history. His path to the NFL was non-traditional, involving three different collegiate stops, which speaks to his unique experience level.

• Full Name: Shilo Deion Sanders
• Birth Date: February 9, 2000 (Age 25 as of the 2025 Draft)
• Hometown: Canton, Texas
• College History: South Carolina Gamecocks (2019-2020), Jackson State Tigers (2021-2022), Colorado Buffaloes (2023-2024)
• Position: Safety (S)
• Height/Weight: 6'0", 195 lbs
• Father: Deion Sanders (NFL Hall of Famer and current Colorado Head Coach)
• Key Collegiate Accomplishment: Led the Colorado Buffaloes in tackles with 70 during his most recent season, demonstrating his impact as a downhill, aggressive defender.
• 2025 NFL Status: Undrafted Free Agent (UDFA) signed by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

Sanders’ six years of collegiate experience provided him with a high football IQ, making him a seasoned veteran in the draft class.

The Shocking 2025 NFL Draft Snub and Steelers' Silence

The biggest surprise surrounding Shilo Sanders in the 2025 NFL Draft was not where he was picked, but the fact that he was not picked at all. Going undrafted was a major blow to a player who was a key defensive leader for the Colorado Buffaloes. The Pittsburgh Steelers, in particular, were a team many analysts and fans pegged as a potential landing spot. The Steelers entered the 2025 offseason with questions at the safety position. While superstar Minkah Fitzpatrick anchors the defense, the depth behind him and the need for a strong, versatile box safety were evident. General Manager Omar Khan and the front office had every opportunity across seven rounds to take a chance on a player with high-level experience and a proven track record of tackling. The silence from the Steelers spoke volumes. They declined to use a draft pick on Sanders, and critically, they did not aggressively pursue him in the immediate aftermath when he became an undrafted free agent. Sanders ultimately chose the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, citing the supportive atmosphere and team culture as a key factor in his decision. This move cemented the fact that the Steelers had a clear stance on Shilo Sanders: they were not interested in allocating a draft pick or a priority UDFA contract to him.

Scouting Report: Why the Steelers Passed on the 'Prime Time' Son

The decision by the Steelers to bypass Shilo Sanders, despite their defensive needs, was likely rooted in a few specific concerns highlighted in his pre-draft scouting reports. While Sanders possesses several undeniable strengths that fit the mold of a hard-nosed Steelers defender, his limitations were significant enough to drop him out of the draft entirely.

1. Age and Athletic Ceiling Concerns

One of the most critical factors was Sanders' age and his overall athletic ceiling. As a six-year college player, Sanders turned 25 before his rookie season. NFL teams, especially the Steelers who often prioritize younger prospects with high upside, prefer players who have fewer miles on their bodies and more room for development. Scouts likely viewed Sanders as a player who had already maxed out his physical potential in college.

2. The 'Downhill' vs. 'Coverage' Specialist Balance

Scouting reports consistently praised Sanders as a "downhill player" and a "big-hitter" who is aggressive against ball-carriers and blockers. This is a classic strong safety trait, which the Steelers value. However, the modern NFL demands safeties with elite range and versatility in coverage. While he is described as an "effective coverage defender," his straight-line speed and lateral quickness were likely not viewed as elite enough to consistently cover the league's fastest slot receivers and tight ends.

3. Positional Value in the Draft

The Steelers’ defensive philosophy, particularly with Minkah Fitzpatrick, often relies on a free safety who can cover a vast amount of ground. While Shilo is a safety, his skillset leans more toward the strong safety role. Given the depth chart, the Steelers may have prioritized other positions or looked for a more pure coverage safety later in the draft. The team’s focus on building a strong secondary through other means may have simply pushed Sanders down their board.

4. Competition Level and Transfer History

Although Sanders finished his career at a Power Five school (Colorado), his collegiate journey included a stop at Jackson State. While he excelled there, scouts often question the level of competition faced at non-FBS schools. Additionally, moving between three different programs (South Carolina, Jackson State, Colorado) might have raised minor flags about consistency or stability, although his commitment to his father's program was a clear motivator.

5. The UDFA Contract Value

Ultimately, the Steelers’ decision was a calculated risk. By passing on Sanders, they gambled that if they truly wanted him, they could outbid other teams in the undrafted free agent pool. When Sanders chose the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, it was a clear signal that the Steelers’ offer or overall appeal was not enough to secure his services. The organization's silence during the UDFA process indicated a lack of priority for the former Colorado star. The connection between Shilo Sanders and the Pittsburgh Steelers will forever be a "what if" scenario from the 2025 NFL Draft. While he begins his professional career with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, his aggressive style and high football IQ will make him a player worth watching. For the Steelers, their decision to pass on a player with his unique profile means they are betting on their existing depth or future draft picks to solve their safety needs.

Detail Author:

• Name : Thalia Kulas
• Username : hromaguera
• Email : aglae37@hotmail.com
• Birthdate : 1973-11-12
• Address : 48559 Bechtelar Street Joanniefort, NC 75523-7128
• Phone : +13147970295
• Company : Hansen Group
• Job : Data Entry Operator
• Bio : Impedit explicabo placeat enim blanditiis non. Autem ut labore quasi rerum quis modi. Aut quia qui qui illum adipisci. Sunt id eius cumque natus.

Socials

instagram:

• url : https://instagram.com/paolod'amore
• username : paolod'amore
• bio : Est corporis facilis sed aut commodi. Placeat eligendi animi molestiae facilis.
• followers : 425
• following : 3000

tiktok:

• url : https://tiktok.com/@paolo_xx
• username : paolo_xx
• bio : Sunt repellendus rem iusto impedit et quis. Harum nihil nostrum minima.
• followers : 6563
• following : 1914

linkedin:

• url : https://linkedin.com/in/paolo_d'amore
• username : paolo_d'amore
• bio : Eum repellendus corporis sit corrupti.
• followers : 249
• following : 2408

facebook:

• url : https://facebook.com/paolo_dev
• username : paolo_dev
• bio : Quidem totam molestiae quisquam.
• followers : 942
• following : 1623

twitter:

• url : https://twitter.com/d'amore1984
• username : d'amore1984
• bio : Est id velit dolorem rem molestiae atque cum magni. Deserunt numquam enim asperiores perferendis voluptas sed. Rerum ipsam sit soluta sit est iure molestias.
• followers : 5524
• following : 2370