Home News Blitz 2

Jillian Michaels's Slavery Comments: 5 Controversial Claims That Sparked A CNN Firestorm And Backlash

• minute read
Contents
The latest controversy surrounding fitness mogul Jillian Michaels has reignited a fierce public debate, stemming from her highly polarized comments on the history of slavery in the United States during a recent appearance on CNN’s *NewsNight with Abby Phillip*. The discussion, which took place in late 2024, quickly went viral, with Michaels making several claims that critics immediately labeled as "historical revisionism" and "whitewashing" of the atrocities of American chattel slavery. This article, updated for December 22, 2025, provides an in-depth breakdown of the specific claims, the immediate backlash, and Michaels's subsequent defense, offering a comprehensive look at one of the most significant political controversies of her career. The core of the dispute centered on a segment discussing a review of Smithsonian exhibits, which led to a broader conversation about race, history, and the legacy of slavery in America. Michaels’s statements, intended to offer a "historical context," were met with immediate pushback from host Abby Phillip and a subsequent firestorm of criticism across social media and news outlets, forcing the former *The Biggest Loser* trainer to defend her position against accusations of downplaying a foundational American tragedy.

Jillian Michaels: Complete Biography and Career Profile

Jillian Leigh McKarus, known professionally as Jillian Michaels, is an American fitness trainer, businesswoman, author, and television personality whose career has been marked by both immense success and frequent controversy. Her tough-love approach to fitness has made her a household name, but her outspoken political and social views have increasingly placed her at the center of public disputes.

  • Full Name: Jillian Leigh McKarus
  • Born: February 18, 1974 (Age 51 as of late 2025)
  • Birthplace: Los Angeles, California, U.S.
  • Occupation: Fitness Trainer, Nutritionist, Author, Businesswoman, Media Personality
  • Known For: Trainer on NBC's reality show The Biggest Loser (2004–2006, 2007–2011, 2013–2014); Creator of the *Jillian Michaels Fitness App*; Host of the podcast *Keeping It Real: Conversations with Jillian Michaels*.
  • Key Publications: *Master Your Metabolism*, *Slim for Life*, *Unlimited: How to Build an Exceptional Life*.
  • Family Life: Michaels is openly lesbian and has two children with her former partner. She is currently married to fashion designer DeShanna Marie Minuto.
  • Career Highlights: Emmy-nominated, successful fitness DVD franchise, and a global health and wellness brand.

The 5 Controversial Claims Michaels Made on CNN

The viral segment on CNN’s *NewsNight* saw Michaels present a series of arguments that were widely interpreted as an attempt to minimize the unique brutality and racialized nature of slavery in the United States. Critics, including historians and commentators like Nikole Hannah-Jones, argued that her claims distorted the historical record and ignored the lasting economic and social impact of the institution.

1. The "Less Than 2% of White Americans Owned Slaves" Statistic

Claim: Michaels repeatedly cited the statistic that "less than 2% of white Americans owned slaves" as a way to argue that the issue was not as widespread as current political discourse suggests.

Controversy: While the number of slave-owning families nationally was indeed a minority, historians and fact-checkers quickly pointed out that this figure is highly misleading. In the South, where the institution of chattel slavery was the economic engine, the percentage of white families who owned slaves was much higher, sometimes reaching 25% or more in certain states. Furthermore, the entire Southern economy and political structure, along with Northern industries, benefitted directly and indirectly from the slave system. To focus solely on the national percentage, critics argued, is to "hide behind that number" and ignore the systemic nature of the institution.

2. Slavery Existed "Across Cultures and Races Throughout History"

Claim: Michaels asserted that slavery is "thousands of years old" and existed "across cultures and races throughout history."

Controversy: This is a common argument used to deflect from the specific nature of American slavery. While various forms of servitude have existed globally, the system of racialized chattel slavery in the U.S. was unique in its brutality. It was based on race, hereditary, and treated enslaved people as literal property—chattel—rather than temporary servants. Critics, including Abby Phillip, pressed Michaels on this point, arguing that her broad historical comparison served only to downplay the unique horror and enduring legacy of American slavery.

3. Americans Were "The First Race to Try to End Slavery"

Claim: In one of her most inflammatory statements, Michaels claimed that Americans were "the first race to try to end slavery."

Controversy: This claim is historically inaccurate and was immediately flagged by multiple commentators. The movement to abolish slavery, known as Abolitionism, was a long, complex, and global effort. Great Britain, for example, abolished the slave trade in 1807 and slavery itself in most of its empire in 1833, decades before the United States fought the Civil War to end the practice. Michaels's phrasing, using the word "race" instead of "nation" or "people," further confused and inflamed the debate.

4. Defending Donald Trump’s Stance on Smithsonian Exhibits

Context: The debate began with a discussion about former President Donald Trump’s administration requesting a review of exhibits at the Smithsonian Institution, which critics saw as an attempt to "whitewash" history, particularly concerning the 1619 Project and the narrative of American origins.

Claim: Michaels defended the idea that Trump was not attempting to whitewash slavery, suggesting that the focus on the historical context of slavery being global was a valid counterpoint to the exhibits. Her defense of the administration's position was seen by many as aligning her with a specific political narrative that seeks to diminish the role of slavery in the nation's founding.

5. Accusing CNN of "Lying" and "Smearing" Her

Claim: Following the intense backlash, Michaels did not apologize or retract her statements. Instead, she doubled down on her claims, telling Fox News Digital and other outlets that CNN and Abby Phillip had "flat out lied" and engaged in a "smearing" campaign against her.

Controversy: This move shifted the focus from the accuracy of her historical claims to a media dispute, framing herself as a victim of "political correctness" and media bias. She argued that her comments were taken out of context, though video evidence of the debate clearly shows her making the specific claims. This reaction only served to further solidify the views of her critics who saw her as unapologetic and unwilling to acknowledge the historical nuances of the issue.

Beyond Slavery: A History of Michaels's Public Controversies

The slavery debate is not the first time Jillian Michaels has faced significant public scrutiny. Her career has been punctuated by several high-profile controversies, demonstrating a pattern of outspokenness that often clashes with prevailing public opinion and expert consensus. These past disputes contribute to the larger context of her public persona and topical authority.

  • The Biggest Loser Health Concerns: Michaels has faced long-standing criticism regarding the extreme weight loss methods promoted on *The Biggest Loser*. A 2024 Netflix documentary, *Fit for TV*, reignited this debate, with former contestants and the show's medical advisor, Dr. Robert Huizenga, discussing the "unhealthy" and unsustainable nature of the rapid weight loss goals. Michaels vehemently rejected these claims, arguing she has the "data" to back up her methods.
  • The Caffeine Pills Scandal: During Season 15 of *The Biggest Loser*, Michaels came under fire for giving her team contestants caffeine pills, a move that violated show rules and raised serious ethical and health concerns.
  • Comments on Lizzo: In 2020, Michaels sparked a separate body-positivity controversy when she questioned why Lizzo's body was being celebrated, stating, "Why are we celebrating her body? Why does it matter?" Critics accused her of fat-shaming and displaying a lack of understanding of the body-positivity movement, further questioning her White privilege in the discussion.
  • COVID-19 Restrictions: She also faced backlash for her political views during the 2020 pandemic, where she criticized certain government-mandated restrictions, aligning herself with more conservative viewpoints.

In conclusion, the "Jillian Michaels slavery" debate serves as a powerful example of the collision between celebrity, political commentary, and historical fact. Her use of specific, misleading statistics and broad historical comparisons to defend a political position resulted in a significant media backlash. While Michaels continues to defend her statements, the controversy has cemented her reputation not just as a fitness guru, but as an increasingly polarizing figure in American political and social discourse.

jillian michaels slavery
jillian michaels slavery

Detail Author:

  • Name : Amir Gulgowski MD
  • Username : zvolkman
  • Email : andreane.heidenreich@gmail.com
  • Birthdate : 1974-07-10
  • Address : 342 Schultz Plains Aliyaville, WY 09255
  • Phone : 651.869.6645
  • Company : Larson Ltd
  • Job : Budget Analyst
  • Bio : Dicta sequi laboriosam amet odio ab. Optio iure eos qui eum assumenda itaque occaecati. Autem deleniti esse dolorum mollitia voluptas. Quae sunt fuga expedita reiciendis.

Socials

twitter:

  • url : https://twitter.com/michelemcdermott
  • username : michelemcdermott
  • bio : Nemo est totam enim porro. Veritatis rerum dolor ex et blanditiis explicabo. Est ut rerum qui quidem.
  • followers : 5263
  • following : 2736

linkedin:

facebook:

Random Posts