The 15 Most Popular Male Hallmark Actors: Their New 2025 Movies And Exclusive Deals
The landscape of the Hallmark Channel has never been more vibrant, and leading the charge into 2025 is a stellar lineup of charismatic male actors who have become synonymous with heartwarming romance and holiday cheer. As of December 2025, the network continues to invest heavily in its top talent, securing multi-picture deals and launching new, high-profile projects that keep fan-favorite stars on screen year-round.
This article dives deep into the careers of the network’s current leading men, revealing their latest movie titles, their surprising off-screen ventures, and the exclusive contracts that confirm their status as the kings of feel-good television. From the beloved "Three Wisest Men" to the stars of *When Calls the Heart*, here is the definitive guide to the Hallmark male actors dominating 2025.
The A-List: Biographies and Confirmed 2025 Projects
The following actors represent the core of Hallmark’s male talent, each with a proven track record and exciting new projects confirmed for the current and upcoming season.
- Andrew Walker: A Montreal native and one of the most prolific leading men, known for his genuine on-screen chemistry, particularly with Lacey Chabert. Walker made his Hallmark debut in 2012's *A Bride for Christmas*. He is also an entrepreneur, having launched his own skincare line, SkinMason.
- Tyler Hynes: The Canadian actor has cultivated a massive, devoted fanbase (known as "Hynies") for his unique, often quirky, and emotionally layered performances. He is known for his signature toothpick and his frequent collaborations with director Paul Ziller.
- Kevin McGarry: Best known for his long-running role as Mountie Nathan Grant on the hit series *When Calls the Heart*. McGarry is a Canadian-born actor, writer, and director who brings a steady, reliable charm to both series and standalone movies.
- Paul Campbell: A Canadian actor who is not only a fan-favorite lead but also a successful writer for the network, often co-writing his own starring vehicles. His creativity has led to some of Hallmark's most successful recent hits.
- Brennan Elliott: A Canadian-born actor celebrated for his versatility, often starring in both romantic comedies and the more dramatic *Hallmark Mystery* titles. He is a frequent co-star of Lacey Chabert, forming one of Hallmark's most iconic on-screen duos.
- Will Kemp: An English actor and professional dancer, Kemp brings a sophisticated, often European flair to his roles. His background in dance frequently influences his on-screen presence, notably in movies with a performance theme.
- Daniel Lissing: An Australian actor who first gained widespread fame as Jack Thornton on *When Calls the Heart*. After a brief departure, his return to the network has been celebrated by fans, solidifying his place as a romantic lead.
- Christopher Russell: A first-generation Canadian actor known for his classic, handsome lead roles in over 15 romantic Hallmark films. He has successfully transitioned from supporting roles to becoming a dependable leading man.
The New Era of Exclusive Multi-Picture Deals
The competition in the family-friendly television space has prompted Hallmark Media to secure its top talent with lucrative, exclusive multi-picture deals. This strategic move ensures that fan-favorite male actors remain the face of the network for years to come, strengthening topical authority and viewer loyalty.
Andrew Walker was one of the first male stars to ink a major overall deal with Crown Media Family Networks, a sign of the network's commitment to his prolific output.
Similarly, English actor Will Kemp signed a multi-picture overall deal, which quickly led to new and diverse projects, including the Jane Austen-themed movie *Paging Mr. Darcy* and the 2024 holiday film *My Sweet Australian Holiday*.
The network also signed Ryan Paevey to an exclusive multi-picture deal, confirming his status as a key leading man despite the competitive market for talent.
The "Three Wisest Men" and Their 2025 Movie Slate
The collaborative trio of Tyler Hynes, Andrew Walker, and Paul Campbell—dubbed "The Three Wisest Men" by fans—have become a massive phenomenon for the network. Their 2022 hit *Three Wise Men and a Baby* was a record-breaker, leading to a highly anticipated follow-up.
Their continued work together, often blending humor and genuine emotion, has created a new sub-genre of Hallmark content. The confirmed 2024 sequel, *Three Wiser Men and a Boy*, starring all three, is one of the most anticipated releases for the holiday season, further cementing their legendary status.
Individual 2025 Project Spotlights
Beyond their collaborative efforts, each of the top male actors has a busy solo schedule, with several confirmed movie titles for the 2025 calendar year:
- Andrew Walker: Fans can look forward to the new Christmas movie, *Falling on Santa's Naughty or Nice*, confirmed for the 2025 "Countdown to Christmas" slate.
- Tyler Hynes: His 2025 lineup includes the highly anticipated holiday romance *Christmas Above the Clouds*. Hynes also starred in an impressive six movies in 2024, demonstrating his prolific output.
- Paul Campbell: In addition to the "Three Wiser Men" sequel, Campbell is confirmed for *Falling Together* in 2024 and is slated for *Christmas at the...* (a working title) in 2025, often showcasing his talent for both acting and writing.
- Kevin McGarry: While continuing his popular role on *When Calls the Heart* (now in its 11th season), McGarry will also star in the standalone movie *Villa Amore*, confirmed for a June 2025 airdate.
- Brennan Elliott: He recently starred in the 2024 Fall into Love movie *His & Hers* alongside his frequent collaborator, Lacey Chabert. Elliott remains a pillar of the network, valued for his dramatic range.
- Daniel Lissing: The Australian heartthrob is confirmed for a 2025 holiday movie titled *Single on the 25th*, following his 2024 reunion movie with Jessica Lowndes.
The Rising Stars and Fan-Favorite Entities
Hallmark's success relies on a deep bench of talent, ensuring that new faces and long-time contributors keep the content fresh and diverse. Several other male actors consistently appear in top-tier projects, building their own loyal fanbases and topical authority.
The Steady Pillars of Hallmark
These actors are recognized staples, consistently delivering quality performances across the network’s various programming blocks, including the popular *Hallmark Mystery* franchise.
- Brooks Darnell: A rising star who signed a multi-picture deal with Hallmark, making him a key part of the network's future. He is known for his charming and relatable performances.
- Luke MacFarlane: Although he has taken on more diverse roles, MacFarlane remains a beloved figure and a veteran of the network, having also signed a multi-picture deal in 2022.
- Chris McNally: The other leading man in *When Calls the Heart*, playing Lucas Bouchard, McNally is a core member of the series cast alongside Kevin McGarry and Erin Krakow.
- Kristoffer Polaha: Known for his unique, slightly edgy roles within the romantic comedy format, Polaha is a reliable presence, often starring in movies with a literary or travel focus.
- Jesse Metcalfe: While he has explored other projects, including action franchises, Metcalfe is still strongly associated with his Hallmark roles, such as the *Martha's Vineyard Mysteries* series.
- Marcus Rosner: A Canadian actor who has steadily climbed the ranks from supporting roles to becoming a frequent, dependable leading man.
The New and Diverse Voices
Hallmark is also expanding its roster to include more diverse storytelling and representation, bringing in new talent to reflect modern romance.
- Jake Foy: Making waves as one of the first openly gay male leads in a Hallmark series, playing cowboy Tuff McMurray on the western drama *Ride*. His role signals the network’s push for broader LGBTQ+ representation.
- Jonathan Bennett: A trailblazer for LGBTQ+ representation on the network, Bennett has starred in several holiday films with gay story lines, including *The Holiday Sitter*. He frequently co-stars with Tyler Hynes in projects like *The Groomsmen Trilogy*.
- James Denton: A veteran actor known for *Desperate Housewives* and *Good Witch*, Denton continues to take on high-profile holiday projects, bringing a familiar, seasoned charm to the cast.
The male Hallmark actors of 2025 are more than just leading men; they are writers, producers, entrepreneurs, and the foundation of a highly successful media brand. Their exclusive deals and busy project schedules confirm that the current wave of talent—led by the powerful trio of Walker, Hynes, and Campbell—will continue to define the network’s feel-good success story for the foreseeable future. The commitment to fresh, new content, and the expansion of diverse voices, ensures that the Hallmark Channel remains the premier destination for romantic and uplifting entertainment.
Detail Author:
- Name : Sean Hansen
- Username : beer.dylan
- Email : celine42@hudson.com
- Birthdate : 1990-03-07
- Address : 6300 Skyla Inlet Lamontbury, SD 83678
- Phone : 828.988.4569
- Company : Sanford and Sons
- Job : Metal-Refining Furnace Operator
- Bio : Dolorem voluptas aut excepturi. Est consequatur aut magni voluptate mollitia animi. Quasi magni voluptatum accusamus similique tempora possimus tempore.
Socials
instagram:
- url : https://instagram.com/torp2010
- username : torp2010
- bio : Dolores eaque enim quisquam aut. Vero dolorum dolorum et quas ab.
- followers : 6451
- following : 256
facebook:
- url : https://facebook.com/torp1985
- username : torp1985
- bio : Aut autem ab qui mollitia non dignissimos tempora.
- followers : 4829
- following : 1003
linkedin:
- url : https://linkedin.com/in/rowena.torp
- username : rowena.torp
- bio : Ratione voluptas enim ut.
- followers : 6476
- following : 2711
twitter:
- url : https://twitter.com/rowena_torp
- username : rowena_torp
- bio : Voluptates voluptate rerum rem ipsa et officia. Et nam possimus pariatur iste nesciunt aut.
- followers : 4323
- following : 2548
tiktok:
- url : https://tiktok.com/@rowena_dev
- username : rowena_dev
- bio : Eos laudantium velit consectetur impedit temporibus.
- followers : 3008
- following : 2781
